Published by Harlequin Teen on March 1st 2016
Genres: Contemporary, Romance, Young Adult
Amazon | Book Depository | Publisher | Angus & Robertson
Add to Goodreads
One punch will shatter a town.
Is anyone ready for the consequences of the truth?
Callie Jones is not the kind of girl who gets drunk at school dances, and certainly not now, with her scholarship on the line. And she definitely doesn’t hang around with bad boys like Rhett Barker. Especially alone, at night. But these are the circumstances she finds herself in when she witnesses a king hit that lands the town’s golden boy in a coma.
With his reputation, no one is less surprised than Rhett when he is accused of throwing the punch. But he didn’t do it. And he knows Callie saw what really went down. He just has to convince the ‘ice princess’ to come forward and talk to the police – except, for once, good girl Callie doesn’t seem all that interested in telling the truth. Just what is she hiding, and why?
Drawn together by secrets, scandal and heartache, Callie and Rhett find themselves getting closer – even as the solution to their problems gets further away.
What I Saw has an important message about doing the right thing and being true to yourself. This book is about the issue of alcohol-fuelled violence and coward punches, which is a prevalent issue in Australia right now. While I really enjoyed and appreciated that the author brought this issue to light, I did have a few qualms about the book.
But let’s address the elephant in the room first, which are the similarities between What I Saw and What We Saw by Aaron Hartzler. I read What We Saw a couple months ago and when I first heard about What I Saw, I was a little bit taken aback by how similar the titles and the premises of the books were. Both of these books feature a horrific incident that is caused by the popular footballers of a small town. These footballers all come from respected families, while the victims/people who have been wrongly accused come from families who are frowned upon and ostracised by everybody else. Both books feature teachers who try to cover up the incident, and in both books, everybody trusts the word of the popular kids. It’s safe to say that I wasn’t very impressed with What I Saw for the first 50 or so pages because it was almost exactly like something else I had read before. However, What I Saw started to go off in a different direction and I was able to start enjoying it a bit more.
This book is about alcohol-fuelled violence and I thought it wasn’t explored well enough. There is an incident caused by a coward punch at the beginning of the book and an act of vandalism half way through the book, which I thought really shone a light on the issue of alcohol-fuelled violence and the consequences that drinking too much can have. However, I thought very little was done to really educate readers on what is appropriate behaviour and responsible drinking. I was missing the important messages that I thought needed to be included in a book about such a serious issue. The only message that I really got from the book, in regards to alcohol-fuelled violence was “don’t punch people when you’re drunk”, which wasn’t really enough, in my opinion. Instead of really focusing on the issue, the book is more about Callie’s internal struggle and development throughout the book, which is a great story but not enough to satisfy me.
“There’s always a choice. You’re not responsible. You can’t take the blame for someone else’s mistake.”
I also thought that some aspects of the story were very unrealistic and I didn’t understand a lot of the decisions that the characters made. Rhett had almost no motivation to clear his name even though he didn’t commit the crime. He’s just resigned to being the bad guy and seemed reluctant to take any steps to clearing up the misunderstanding, despite his acknowledgement that his family depends on him. I was baffled by all of his mental and physical running away, and at times it felt super melodramatic. I also couldn’t understand Callie’s thought processes and why she continued to accept drinks from everyone when she felt guilty about drinking and ruining her scholarship chances. But what I couldn’t understand most of all was why charges hadn’t been pressed against Rhett, if everybody assumed he was the perpetrator. I thought it was super unrealistic that the parents of the victim of the one punch attack were constantly by his hospital bed but hadn’t pressed charges immediately. I feel like I spent the whole book waiting for things that, in my opinion, needed to happen to happen, but they never did and the story just never felt genuine or realistic to me.
I also couldn’t really get on board with the romance. It was extremely insta-lovey and things developed much too quickly. The timeline of the book spans about 3 days and I was just frustrated by how quickly things were happening. They go from being strangers to kissing within the span of a day and a half, and during this time, Callie even managed to break up with her douche of a boyfriend. It just seemed really unrealistic and I would’ve liked the book a lot more if it focused less on the romance and more on the important issues of alcohol and violence. In addition to the insta-love, what I didn’t like about the romance was the extra influence it had on Callie’s decision about coming forward with the truth. I would have much preferred if she had made her decision purely on what she believes is right, and not because she had feelings for Rhett. I mean, I liked that they got to know each other but it added a lot of unnecessary drama, especially when Rhett kept telling Callie that he won’t be mad if she doesn’t tell the truth and even encouraged her to hide the truth. WUT?!
Despite the criticisms that I have, I thought there was a lot to like about the book. I enjoyed the characters a lot, even though they were slightly cliched at times. They weren’t dislikeable and I liked the dynamics between the characters. I also liked that the book was written from dual perspectives. It gave me a chance to get to know both characters and it made it easier to understand some of the decisions they made (though some of them still had me baffled). Their voices could have been a little bit more distinct but I was never confused about whose perspective I was reading from.
Overall, I thought this was a solid book. It did contain a lot of elements that I’ve read in other contemporary novels but I was still able to appreciate what the author was trying to do. I appreciated that she tried to highlight a serious issue that we’ve been seeing a lot in the news and media, but I do wish that it was tackled a little bit better. There was a bit too much focus on the romance and the characters, and not enough on the issue that the author was trying to highlight.
Rating: 3 out of 5
Thanks to Harlequin Teen Australia for sending me this book for review!
Latest posts by Jenna (see all)
- Love on the Brain Review: Deja Vu? - September 1, 2022
- The No-Show Review: Definitely Not What It Seems - July 28, 2022
- Something Wilder Review: A Wild, Adventure-Filled Story - June 30, 2022
Yes the similarities between this book and What We Saw by Aaron Hartzler are a little bit disturbing. I agree that if the author tackles a serious issue in their book, they need to provide some message.
My recent post Review: The Score (Off-Campus #3) by Elle Kennedy
First off, at first glance I thought the title read "What I sah" haha. Definitely had to do a double take. Interesting that there is two such similar books out there, but I mean, this is an issue that's not new. There's bound to be many more that deal with the same issue using a similar cast of characters (although it's quite cliche). I would actually like to see it flipped around. Sad to hear that the education and the key messages were not done well. I guess it's a small step in the right direction, but we definitely need to find better ways to educate people about how wrong this is. Lovely review Jenna!
Haha I had an ARC copy with a blank cover so I didn't notice the title but I totally see what you mean now! I definitely hope that there are many more books about alcohol-fulled violence to come because it's an issue that really needs to be explored. Novels are a great way of educating young people about responsible drinking but the messages need to actually be in the book, which I thought this book lacked a little. It was all a bit too implicit.
Again with the romance! If anything books should show us, especially young readers, the virtue of timing. If your life is a mess maybe it's not the best time to be in a relationship because most likely you'll be prone to insta love out of desperation and you'll fall prey to bad judgment. #bitterbites
My recent post Gush & Gripe: Seasoned Romances #discussion
Exactly! I wish authors would leave the romance out of issues books so that the issues are actually explored. We don't need all this romance clouding the characters' judgments.
NO UGH these characters don't sound too smart to me. :(( And the message about alcoholism sounds like there's so many things missing! I have too little time to read about contemporaries with insta-love, hah.
Yeah, the characters were just not great. The insta-love and romance bothered me so much that I just couldn't really deal with the characters…
Wow, not only similar title names, but similar premise? I'm not sure if I want to read the two just to compare or what. I love issue books, but sometimes it's not properly done and that leaves me feeling meh about it. There's always that one defining moment in the book that makes me give it a 3 star rating, instead of something less. Despite the issues, I'm really curious now. Great review!
My recent post Waiting On Wednesday #26 The Only Thing Worse Than Me Is You
The similar premise really bothered me at the beginning! I couldn't really separate it from What We Saw because of the similar titles. And to find that a lot of the elements were the same, was a little bit off-putting to be honest. But it slowly started to deviate from What We Saw and I think that's when I started to enjoy it a little bit more. It could have explored the issues a lot more, but I'm still glad that this book exists and that I read it!
I haven't heard of this one but I have heard of What We Saw. I'm thinking maybe I should read that one instead because I know a lot of people loved that one.
You should definitely read What We Saw. I really loved that book and it had lots of great messages in it about sexual assault and slut shaming. I thought it was a really informative and important book, which was probably another reason why What I Saw was kind of disappointing. It just didn't compare.
That's a real shame that the issues weren't explored well enough, Jenna. With a book with a theme like this one, I would definitely expect a thorough exploration of the subject matter. I don't really like the sound of the romance either. I'm not one for insta-love! I'm glad that there were still parts you enjoyed though.
My recent post Monthly Recap: February 2016
The insta-love was particularly bad in this one. Everything just moved way too quickly because of the 2-3 day timeframe that the book is set in. The short timeframe also didn't allow for a thorough exploration of the things that mattered, so it was slightly disappointing. I'm glad that the book still exists in the world though 🙂
It's interesting how this book features coward punches and alcohol fuelled violence, and bases an engaging story around that. The 3 day time frame definitely sounds like it could make things move way too fast when it comes to the romance. Glad you enjoyed it Jenna!
Yeah, I definitely wish there wasn't any romance at all because it kind of overshadowed everything. It could have been a really great issue book but instead, the insta-love kinda killed it. It was still a good book, but What We Saw was better executed.
I disliked the romance so much – they were cute together – but wayyyy to insta-love. Like just, it's up in your face.
Thanks for the review!
My recent post February Wrap Up (2016)
Exactly! It was just too focused on the romance and not enough on the things that really mattered. That insta-love was just ridiculous!